We're updating the issue view to help you get more done. 

Metadata should not be directly associated with ProgramRunIds

Description

In CDAP 5.0 we added support to add metadata to custom entities (non-cdap entities) this allows user to add metadata to any cdap entity too (before CDAP 5.0 it was limited to few CDAP entities). For example now a user can add metadata to ProgramRunId too.

Before CDAP 5.0 RunIds did not have any metadata associated with them directly although we did supported getMetadata call on RunIds which used to aggregate all the metadata of entities associated with that run (dataset, application etc) and return all of them.

In CDAP 5.0 and later we will have to support this aggregation behavior but an open product question is whether user should be able to add metadata directly to a run or not. If they can then ideally the retrieve call should return aggregate metadata for all the entities associated with the run including the metadata directly associated with the run itself.

 

Release Notes

Deprecated the aggregation of metadata annotated with all the entities (application, programs, dataset, streams) associated in a run. From this release onwards metadata for program runs behaves like any other entity where a metadata can be directly annotated to it and retrieved from it. For backward compatibility, to achieve the new behavior an additional query parameter 'runAggregation' should be set to false while making the REST call to retrieve metadata of program runs.

Activity

Show:
Rohit Sinha
July 13, 2018, 5:17 PM

Discussing the changes which will be required to resolve this as of now. 

Rohit Sinha
July 16, 2018, 2:15 PM

After discussion with and and also looking through the our existing code base we did not find any usage of metadata for runId where the aggregation of involved entities is serving a use case.

Discussed with and that we will deprecate this behavior in 5.0 and remove it in coming releases. From 5.0 RunId for metadata will behave like any other entity.

For detailed context of the issue and the changes please see description here:

Rohit Sinha
July 16, 2018, 2:16 PM
Edited
Fixed

Assignee

Rohit Sinha

Reporter

Rohit Sinha

Labels

None

Docs Impact

None

UX Impact

None

Components

Fix versions

Affects versions

Priority

Major
Configure